Economist Herman Daly
Economist Herman Daly
Economist Herman Daly characterizes neo-classical economic theory as being analogous to a biologist trying to understand the functioning of an animal by considering only its circulatory system and ignoring its digestive system which connects the animal “firmly to the environment at both ends!” How is this analogous to neo-classical economic theory? What kind of environmental problems does this kind of neo-classical economic thinking lead to? Explain and provide examples. Must be minimum 400 words with at least 1 reference (Economist Herman Daly)
[NOTE: Carefully compare the anatomy of the circulatory system with the anatomy of the digestive system before answering this question: The circulatory system includes the heart and the blood vessels. The digestive system includes the mouth, esophagus, stomach, intestines, and anus.
Answer
Herman Daly’s analogy of neo-classical economic theory likened to a biologist focusing only on the circulatory system of an animal and ignoring its digestive system highlights a critical perspective on how traditional economics often neglects the interconnectedness between the economy and the environment. (Economist Herman Daly)
Analogy to Neo-Classical Economic Theory:
Focus on Market Transactions (Circulatory System):
Neo-classical economics typically emphasizes market transactions, prices, and GDP growth as the primary indicators of economic health.
This focus mirrors the biologist examining the circulatory system, which deals with the flow of resources (money, goods, services) within the economy.
Neglect of Environmental Inputs and Outputs (Digestive System):
Just as ignoring the digestive system would overlook how an animal interacts with its environment (input of nutrients, output of waste), neo-classical economics often neglects the environment’s role as a source of resources (inputs) and a sink for waste and pollution (outputs).
Daly argues that the economy, like an animal’s digestive system, is firmly connected to the environment at both ends. Inputs from the environment (natural resources) are essential for economic production, and outputs (pollution, waste) affect the environment’s capacity to sustain life and economic activities.
Environmental Problems Due to Neo-Classical Economic Thinking
Overexploitation of Natural Resources
Neo-classical economics often promotes the idea of limitless growth based on resource extraction. This can lead to overexploitation of natural resources such as forests, minerals, and fisheries, depleting these resources faster than they can regenerate.
Example: Deforestation driven by logging industries without sufficient consideration for forest regeneration or biodiversity loss.
Environmental Degradation and Pollution
Neglecting the environmental costs of economic activities can result in pollution and environmental degradation.
Example: Industrial emissions of greenhouse gases contributing to climate change, water pollution from industrial waste, and agricultural runoff causing eutrophication. (Economist Herman Daly)
Externalities and Market Failures
Neo-classical economics often struggles to account for externalities, where the costs or benefits of economic activities are not reflected in market prices.
Example: The costs of environmental damage (e.g., health impacts from pollution) are not borne by the polluters but by society or future generations.
Loss of Ecosystem Services
Ecosystem services provided by natural ecosystems (such as pollination, water purification, climate regulation) are undervalued or ignored in traditional economic models.
Example: Wetlands destruction leading to loss of flood regulation services, exacerbating flood risks for nearby communities.
Conclusion
Herman Daly’s analogy critiques the narrow focus of neo-classical economics on market transactions and economic growth while neglecting the broader ecological context in which economic activities occur. This neglect can lead to unsustainable resource use, environmental degradation, and social costs that are not accounted for in economic decision-making. Recognizing the interconnectedness between the economy and the environment is crucial for addressing environmental challenges and achieving sustainable development. (Economist Herman Daly)
References
https://www.amazon.com/Beyond-Growth-Economics-Sustainable-Development/dp/0807047058
https://www.globalforestwatch.org/
https://www.millenniumassessment.org/documents/document.356.aspx.pdf
